I like Supergirl as top or co-top of all the DC shows right now, but I do recognise other ones like The Flash tends to have less structural problems (e.g a persistently relevant season villain, no dislikeable characters, no random decisions like James to Guardian). Still the best parts of this show shines and carries it so to me the small amount of faults are neligible. Compared to Arrow right now which is plagued by a set of similar and different problems, which currently I still watch but find somewhat boring, SG is in a great place.

If all issues are fixed, Supergirl legit going to rationally speaking be #1 (To me it already is lol)

SERIOUSLY????? Riverdale is ahead of Supergirl and Arrow? Oh good grief, well they just put that list in the "forget about it" category.

yeah jane the virgin and crazy ex-girlfriend are 1 and 2 on this list. I mean Arrow and probably the vampire diaries should be in the top 3 as for impact on the network as both spawned spin offs and were reasonable hits for the network. not sure what the criteria was for this list.

SERIOUSLY????? Riverdale is ahead of Supergirl and Arrow? Oh good grief, well they just put that list in the "forget about it" category.

Very nice.

If the show remains consistent (esp. fixing plot holes, fact-checking plausibility factors, appropriate character insertions/additions into the show and dialogue believability gaps) and the storylines remain tight and cohesive, then the rankings will rise over time. 24 may become 14 and then 4...